LESSON · BLAKE · 14 MIN
Science: The Tree of Death and the Science That Reigns
Two kinds of knowing, and why the real one is tested by its fruit
William Blake seems to say two opposite things about science. On one engraving he wrote, "SCIENCE is the Tree of DEATH." In The Book of Urizen, science is the curtain the Eternals weave to hide the fall. But The Four Zoas ends with "sweet Science reigns," and in Milton science is one of the four great arts of Eternity, the one that stays with us "thro Mercy." He isn't contradicting himself. He's describing two kinds of knowing. One is knowledge cut off from life: measuring, demonstrating, doubting, from a distance. The other is knowledge that comes from inside experience, the way Adam "knew" Eve. Scripture has the same two, and it gives one test for telling them apart: "by their fruits ye shall know them."
The word
"Science" comes from the Latin scientia, "knowledge," from scire, "to know." When Blake says "Science," he means knowing, in the widest sense.
The KJV uses the word twice:
The true kind. Daniel and his friends were "skilful in all wisdom, and cunning in knowledge, and understanding science" (Daniel 1:4). "Science" there is madda (H4093), "intelligence or consciousness."
The false kind. Paul warns Timothy about "oppositions of science falsely so called" (1 Timothy 6:20). "Science" is gnōsis (G1108), "knowing (the act)."
Already in Scripture there's a real science and a false one.
The root: two kinds of knowing
Madda comes from yada (H3045), the great Hebrew verb for knowing. Strong's: "to know (properly, to ascertain by seeing)," used "in a great variety of senses... including observation, care, recognition."
That one verb names both kinds of knowing in Genesis:
Knowledge as a tree you eat from. "The tree of knowledge of good and evil" (Genesis 2:9). "Knowledge" is da'at (H1847), from yada. This is knowledge as something you grab and possess: judging, sorting good from bad, standing outside life and assessing it. Its fruit was death. (See Eden and the Two Trees.)
Knowledge as union. "And Adam knew Eve his wife; and she conceived" (Genesis 4:1). Same verb, yada. Here knowing is the most intimate experience two people can share, and its fruit is new life.
Same word. One kind of knowing stands outside and judges. The other goes inside and joins. The first is the tree of death. The second bears children.
The science that's the Tree of Death
On his Laocoön engraving, Blake set the two side by side: "ART is the Tree of LIFE." "SCIENCE is the Tree of DEATH" (Laocoön).
He's talking about the fallen kind: knowledge that only measures. Here's how Blake describes it across his books.
The curtain over the wound
In The Book of Urizen, when the first separation happens, the Eternals can't bear to look. "Spread a Tent, with strong curtains around them... That Eternals may no more behold them." And they weave it: "With infinite labour the Eternals / A woof wove, and called it Science" (The Book of Urizen 19).
Fallen science is a fabric woven over a wound. It describes the world in detail so that no one has to feel what's wrong with it. You can know everything about a broken thing and never touch it. (See The First Separation.)
The dull round
In one of his earliest works, There is No Natural Religion, Blake explains what happens when knowledge is only measurement: "If it were not for the Poetic or Prophetic character. the Philosophic & Experimental would soon be at the ratio of all things & stand still, unable to do other than repeat the same dull round over again" (There is No Natural Religion).
Notice what he does not say. He doesn't say experiment is bad. He says experiment without the poetic or prophetic, without imagination, gets stuck: it can only repeat what it already knows. And: "He who sees the Infinite in all things sees God. He who sees the Ratio only sees himself only" (There is No Natural Religion). The "Ratio" is the measured relation between things. If that's all you see, you're only seeing the shape of your own measuring. (See Fourfold Vision.)
The idiot Questioner
In Milton, among the things to be cast off, Blake names a figure everyone recognizes: "the idiot Questioner who is always questioning, / But never capable of answering; who sits with a sly grin / Silent plotting when to question, like a thief in a cave; / Who publishes doubt & calls it knowledge; whose Science is Despair / Whose pretence to knowledge is Envy" (Milton 47).
That's the monitor dressed as a scientist: doubt that never tests anything, only undermines. "Science is Despair." Questioning as a pose, not a search.
The arts of death
In Jerusalem, the fall is described as a factory: "And all the Arts of Life they changd into the Arts of Death" (Jerusalem 65). Knowledge put to work for war, profit and control.
The science that reigns
And yet Blake keeps science in Eternity. In Milton he lists what's real there:
"But in Eternity the Four Arts: Poetry, Painting, Music, / And Architecture which is Science: are the Four Faces of Man" (Milton 28).
Science, in Eternity, is architecture: building, structure, the art of form. It's one of the four faces of the whole human, next to poetry, painting and music. (See The Four Zoas.)
Then he says what happens to the four arts in our world: "Not so in Time & Space: there Three are shut out, and only / Science remains thro Mercy: & by means of Science, the Three / Become apparent in time & space, in the Three Professions / Poetry in Religion: Music, Law: Painting, in Physic & Surgery: / That Man may live upon Earth till the time of his awaking, / And from these Three, Science derives every Occupation of Men" (Milton 28).
That's remarkable. In this fallen world, Blake says, science is the art that remains, "thro Mercy." It's how the other arts survive here: poetry as religion, music as law, painting as medicine. Science is how people "live upon Earth till the time of his awaking." Every human occupation comes from it.
And nature itself: "Thus Nature is a Vision of the Science of the Elohim" (Milton 30). The natural world is God's science made visible.
So at the end of The Four Zoas, when everything is restored, Urthona, imagination, rises "to form the golden armour of science / For intellectual War The war of swords departed now / The dark Religions are departed & sweet Science reigns" (The Four Zoas, Night 9).
Sweet Science is knowledge rejoined to imagination: knowing from inside, building, testing, delighting. (See Los.)
The Science of Wrath and the Science of Pity
One more line from Milton shows how deep this goes. In the quarrel at the heart of the Bard's song, Blake writes: "And Satan not having the Science of Wrath, but only of Pity: / Rent them asunder, and wrath was left to wrath, & pity to pity" (Milton 8).
There's a science of feeling, a real knowledge of how to work with wrath. Satan doesn't have it. He only knows pity, and pity divides. True science includes knowing how the heart works, not just how the stars move.
True science in Scripture: tested by fruit
So what is the unfallen science? Scripture's answer is very practical. It's knowledge you get by testing things in your own life and seeing what they produce.
Prove all things. "Prove all things; hold fast that which is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21). "Prove" is dokimazō (G1381), "to test (literally or figuratively); by implication, to approve." Not believe all things, not reject all things. Test them, and keep what proves good.
Test God himself. "And prove me now herewith, saith the LORD of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven" (Malachi 3:10). "Prove" is bachan (H974), "to test (especially metals); generally and figuratively, to investigate." It's the word for assaying metal in a furnace: the smith's test. God invites the experiment.
Taste and see. "O taste and see that the LORD is good" (Psalm 34:8). Knowledge by tasting.
Do it, and you'll know. "If any man will do his will, he shall know of the doctrine, whether it be of God, or whether I speak of myself" (John 7:17). The knowing comes after the doing. You can't learn it from outside.
Come and see. When two disciples ask Jesus where he's staying, he doesn't explain. "He saith unto them, Come and see" (John 1:39).
Try the spirits. "Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God" (1 John 4:1).
Be doers. "But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves" (James 1:22). Knowing without doing is self-deception.
By their fruits
And the measure of every test is fruit: "Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit... Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire. Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them" (Matthew 7:17–20).
That's the experimental method in one sentence. Don't judge a teaching, a practice or a belief by how it sounds. Watch what it produces in a life.
The fig tree: an experiment with a season
Jesus tells a parable that's almost a lab protocol: "A certain man had a fig tree planted in his vineyard; and he came and sought fruit thereon, and found none. Then said he unto the dresser of his vineyard, Behold, these three years I come seeking fruit on this fig tree, and find none: cut it down; why cumbereth it the ground? And he answering said unto him, Lord, let it alone this year also, till I shall dig about it, and dung it: And if it bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that thou shalt cut it down" (Luke 13:6–9).
Look at the structure:
Observe: three years, no fruit.
Don't cut too soon: "let it alone this year also."
Change the conditions: "dig about it, and dung it."
Set a time frame: one more year.
Judge by the result: fruit, or cut it down.
That's true science: patient, caring, honest about results. Not the idiot Questioner's endless doubt, and not blind belief. A real test, with real care, and a real verdict.
And the other fig tree, the one Jesus cursed, is the warning: "he found nothing but leaves" (Mark 11:13). Leaves are the show of life: talk, appearance, knowledge on display. Fruit is life itself. Remember that fig leaves were the first thing humans made after eating from the tree of knowledge (Genesis 3:7). Knowledge without fruit is all leaves. (See Garments.)
Knowledge and love
Paul ties it together: "Knowledge puffeth up, but charity edifieth. And if any man think that he knoweth any thing, he knoweth nothing yet as he ought to know. But if any man love God, the same is known of him" (1 Corinthians 8:1–3).
Fallen science is knowing about. True science ends in being known: yada again, the knowing of union. And he prays for knowledge joined to love: "that your love may abound yet more and more in knowledge and in all judgment; That ye may approve things that are excellent" (Philippians 1:9–10). "Approve" is dokimazō again: love that tests.
A systems bridge
The systems thinker Russell Ackoff drew a distinction that fits Blake closely. Analysis, he argued, takes a thing apart to explain how its pieces work, and that gives you knowledge. Synthesis looks at the larger whole a thing belongs to, to see what it's for, and that gives you understanding. Urizen divides "times on times." Los builds. Both are needed, but the science that reigns is the one that sees the whole.
The two sciences side by side
| Fallen science | The science that reigns |
|---|---|
| "SCIENCE is the Tree of DEATH" | "Architecture which is Science" |
| The tree of da'at, grabbed | Yada, knowing by union |
| A curtain woven over the wound | Building what lasts: Golgonooza |
| "The same dull round" | Experiment joined to vision |
| Sees "the Ratio only" | Sees "the Infinite in all things" |
| The idiot Questioner: doubt as a pose | "Prove all things; hold fast that which is good" |
| Knowing about | Being known |
| Leaves | Fruit |
| Arts of Death | "Sweet Science reigns" |
How the two sciences show up in a life
Fallen: you read about a practice for years and never try it. You know all about prayer, breathwork or forgiveness, and haven't done any.
Fallen: you doubt everything as a way of protecting yourself, and call it being smart.
Fallen: you measure your life to avoid feeling it: the numbers, the stats, the analysis.
True: you form a guess about what might help, try it for a set season, and watch honestly for fruit.
True: you give a practice real care before judging it: "dig about it, and dung it."
True: when something doesn't bear fruit after a fair test, you let it go.
What it shows you
Blake has two sciences, and so does Scripture.
One verb, yada, names both: knowledge grabbed and knowledge by union.
Fallen science is a curtain over the wound, or doubt that never tests anything.
Experiment without imagination repeats "the same dull round."
In Eternity, science is architecture, one of the four faces of the human.
In this world, science remains "thro Mercy," carrying the other arts.
Nature is "a Vision of the Science of the Elohim."
True science tests, and judges by fruit. "Prove all things."
The fig tree parable is a patient experiment: observe, care, set a season, judge by fruit.
Leaves aren't fruit. Knowledge on display isn't life.
Real knowing ends in being known.
Practice: one honest experiment
Pick one claim. Choose one thing you've been told helps: a verse, a practice, a habit. Something you've heard about but never really tested.
Make it a hypothesis. Write it down plainly: "If I do this, I expect this fruit."
Set the season. Choose a time frame, like the fig tree's year: seven days, thirty days, forty days.
Dig and dung. Give it real care: do it properly, every day, not halfway.
Watch for fruit, honestly. What actually changed? Love, joy, peace, patience? Or only leaves: more talk, more knowledge, more pride?
Hold fast or cut down. Keep what bore fruit. Let go of what didn't, without shame. That's "Prove all things; hold fast that which is good."
Catch the Questioner. When you notice doubt that never tests anything, only undermines, name it: "the idiot Questioner." Then turn the doubt into a test.